10 Best Tomato Substitutes For Cooking

Best Tomato Subtitutes

best tomato substitutes

Tomatoes are a versatile and popular fruit that has been used in cooking for centuries. They are part of the nightshade family and come in a variety of colors, including red, yellow, and green. Tomatoes originated in South America and there are over 10,000 varieties.

They were introduced to Europe in the 16th century but were once believed to be poisonous. Tomatoes provide a tangy flavor with some varieties offering a sweeter or more sour taste.

Tomatoes are widely used in many recipes such as salads, sauces, and chutneys. They can also be eaten raw or cooked depending on the recipe. Tomatoes are high in vitamins A and C as well as potassium and fiber which makes them an excellent addition to any diet.

They can also be canned or frozen for later use making them an ideal ingredient for meal prepping. Tomatoes can also be used to make juice or paste which is often used as a base for soups and stews.

Reasons For A Substitute

Substituting tomato sauce can be necessary for a variety of reasons. For example, if an ingredient is missing from a recipe or if someone has a tomato allergy, then a substitute may be needed.

Additionally, people with heartburn or acid reflux may want to avoid tomato sauce as it can trigger these conditions. Tomatoes are also part of the nightshade family, which contain small amounts of alkaloids that can be dangerous in large doses.

Certain diets advise limiting or avoiding nightshades due to the possibility that they can promote inflammation, although research has not yet confirmed this connection.

When choosing a tomato sauce substitute, it is important to consider why you are swapping your sauce in order to choose the best option for you and your meal.

Running out of an ingredient is a common reason to need a substitute and non-tomato-based substitutes can provide robust and rich flavors while shifting the flavor of the dish.

Best Tomato Substitutes

tomato substitute

Tomatoes are a staple ingredient in many recipes, but sometimes they can be hard to find or you may not like the taste. Fortunately, there are plenty of tomato substitutes that can be used in place of fresh tomatoes.

Red Bell Pepper

Red bell peppers are versatile and flavorful ingredients that can be used in many dishes. They have a sweet, mild flavor that adds depth to sauces, soups, stews, stir-fries, and salads.

Roasting red bell peppers can give them a smoky flavor that enhances the flavor of the dish. Green bell peppers may be too bitter for some recipes, so it is best to use red, yellow, or orange varieties instead.

Red bell peppers also make a great substitute for tomatoes in recipes. They provide a similar bright red color and texture but with a sweeter taste. Red bell peppers are an excellent way to add flavor and color to any dish without overpowering it with tomato acidity.

Tamarind Paste

Tamarind paste is a popular condiment used in many cuisines around the world. It is made from the fruit of a tamarind tree and has a sour and sweet taste.

Tamarind paste can be found in Latin American, Asian, and Indian markets and has a long shelf life when stored in the fridge. This makes it an ideal ingredient for curries as it replicates the sweet tanginess of tomatoes.

Tamarind paste can be bought pre-made at the supermarket or made at home with fresh tamarind fruit. Once prepared, tamarind paste should be stored in a dry and cool place to ensure its longevity. With its unique flavor profile, tamarind paste is an essential ingredient for many dishes around the world.


top tomato substitute

Pumpkins are a type of winter squash that has been around for centuries. They originated in Mexico and the United States, but are now widely used around the world. Pumpkins come in a variety of colors ranging from dark yellow to orange.

Not only do they look great as decorations, but they are also incredibly nutritious. Pumpkins contain high levels of vitamin A and can be used as a substitute for tomatoes in recipes, a little amount of vinegar can mimic the acidity of tomatoes if wanted.

They are also rich in dietary fiber, which helps to keep your digestive system running smoothly. In addition to being delicious when cooked or roasted, pumpkins can also be used to make soups and pies. With their sweet flavor and bright color, pumpkins make a great addition to any meal or snack.


Mango is a delicious and versatile tropical fruit that has been enjoyed for centuries. Originating in southern Asia, mangoes are now grown around the world. The flavor and texture of mangoes can vary depending on the variety and ripeness.

Unripe mangoes have a tarter, less sweet taste than ripe ones, making them an excellent substitute for tomatoes in curries. Mango can also be used as a tomato substitute in salads, adding a unique sweetness to the dish.

Mangoes are packed with nutrients such as vitamins A and C, potassium, magnesium, and fiber. They are also low in calories and fat-free, making them an ideal snack or addition to any meal.

They can also be juiced or blended into smoothies for a refreshing treat. With its many uses and health benefits, it’s no wonder why mango is one of the most popular fruits worldwide.

Canned Tomatoes

one of the tomato substitutes

Canned tomatoes are a great choice for cooking due to their thicker texture and ability to react better under heat exposure. They can be used as a substitute for tomato paste, with two tablespoons of canned tomatoes replacing every tablespoon of tomato paste.

The best options when replacing tomato paste with canned tomatoes are diced or stewed tomatoes, but fire-roasted and crushed tomatoes also work well. Canned tomatoes can also be used as a substitute for sauce, providing a chunky texture to sauces.

When using canned tomatoes as a substitute for either tomato paste or sauce, it is important to note that they come pre-seasoned or unseasoned.

If unseasoned, herbs and spices may need to be added in order to achieve the desired flavor profile. Canned tomatoes work best in stews or spreads, but can also be added to pasta sauce for an extra boost of flavor and texture.

Tomato Paste

Tomato paste is a thick, concentrated tomato sauce that can be used to add flavor and texture to dishes. It is made by draining any excess liquid from canned whole or diced tomatoes, blending the tomatoes, and adding them to a pan.

The mixture should then be cooked for 7-10 minutes before being transferred to a sauce pot and cooked for at least 10 minutes on medium heat. This process reduces the water content of the tomatoes, resulting in a thick paste with intense flavor.

Tomato paste can be used as an ingredient in many dishes such as soups, stews, sauces, and casseroles. It adds depth of flavor and helps thicken sauces without having to use additional ingredients like flour or cornstarch. Tomato paste can also be used as a marinade for meats or vegetables, giving them an extra boost of flavor.

Additionally, it can be added to pizza dough or flatbreads for an extra layer of flavor. With its intense flavor and versatility, tomato paste is a great substitute for fresh tomatoes in many recipes.


one of the best tomato ketchup

Ketchup can be used as a substitute for tomato in recipes. This makes it an ideal ingredient for dishes like chili, baked beans, and braised meat. Ketchup has a unique flavor profile that adds depth to any dish.

It is thinner than tomato paste, so it can be used as an alternative when you want to add more liquid to your dish without changing the flavor too much. For every tomato in a recipe, use one tablespoon of ketchup instead.

This will give your dish an extra kick of sweetness and tanginess that will make it stand out from the rest. Ketchup is also a great way to add color to your dish without having to use tomatoes.

It has a deep red hue that can make any dish look more appetizing. Plus, it’s an easy and convenient way to add flavor without having to chop or cook fresh tomatoes.


Olives are a unique and flavorful addition to many dishes. They offer a savory umami flavor that is similar to tomatoes, making them a great alternative for those who can’t eat nightshades. Olives are also an excellent substitute for sun-dried tomatoes, as they provide the same depth of flavor without the need for drying.

The darker the olive, the better it will taste; this is because darker olives have been cured longer and therefore have more intense flavors. Olives are incredibly versatile and can be used in salads, sandwiches, pasta, pizzas, and more. They can also be eaten on their own as a snack or appetizer.


good tomato substitutes

Cheese is a versatile ingredient that can add a delicious umami flavor to any dish. It can be used in a variety of ways, from crumbled feta or shaved parmesan on salads and salsas, to adding flavor to meals as an alternative to tomato.

Feta and parmesan are two popular types of cheese that are great for adding to salads or sandwiches. Feta has a salty and tangy flavor that pairs well with other ingredients such as olives and tomatoes.

Parmesan has a nutty and sharp taste that adds depth of flavor to dishes. Both kinds of cheese can be used in different recipes, from pasta dishes to pizzas, giving them an extra layer of flavor.

Tomato Sauce

Tomato sauce is a great way to add tomato flavoring to recipes. It is made using ingredients like tomato puree, extra virgin olive oil, vegetable broth, and seasonings. Tomato sauce can be used for soups, stews, and sauces but the other liquids in the recipe will need to be adjusted accordingly.

The difference between tomato sauce and tomato paste is in texture and flavor, with the former being lighter and more liquid than the latter. Tomato sauce is a widely available tomato-based product with sweet notes from added sugar.

When substituting tomato with tomato sauce, it’s important to double the quantity of the sauce in the recipe and remove one tablespoon of another liquid element to even out the dish. This ensures that your dish doesn’t become too watery or too thick due to an incorrect ratio of liquids.

Additionally, adding some herbs or spices can help enhance the flavor of your dish when using tomato sauce as a substitute for tomato.

How To Choose A Tomato Substitute

Tomatoes are a flexible ingredient that can be used in a variety of dishes. However, sometimes it is necessary to find an appropriate substitute for tomatoes. When choosing a tomato substitute, it is important to consider the dish you are preparing and your personal taste.

Fresh tomatoes are always a safe choice, but other forms such as canned tomatoes, tomato sauce, tomato puree, etc. can also be used. It is also important to identify the role of the tomato in a recipe before deciding on an appropriate substitution.

Tomatoes can act as a thickening agent in sauces or soups; they can add sourness to a dish; or they can provide sweetness and texture. Depending on the role of the tomato, you may need to choose a substitute that provides similar qualities.


In conclusion, there are many alternatives to tomatoes that can be used in cooking recipes. These options above provide the same texture and taste as tomatoes without color. For those who cannot live without tomatoes, these options can be of great help.

Recent Posts