How to Thicken Tomato Sauce For Pizza?

If you are a pizza lover, chances are you have had one of those moments where your sauce is too thin.

You can’t spread it in the pan and it just slides off in all directions when you try to pick up the slice. Here’s how to fix that problem by thickening tomato sauce for pizza!

Let’s take a look.

How to thicken tomato sauce for pizza?

Use tomato paste to thicken it

To thicken your tomato sauce, you can use tomato paste. This is the easiest way to do it at home.

You can find commercial tomato pastes that have a lot of flavor additives and these will give your pizza sauce some thickness. But most of them have spices and seasonings too.

Your pizza can taste different if you add other ingredients. If you do not want your pizza to taste different, then you should test it first. If you want your pizza to taste different, then any tomato paste will work for your pizza.

Reduce the tomato juice

You need to drain the excess liquid from the tomatoes before you put them on your pizza.

It is okay if there is a little water in the tinned tomatoes, but don’t pick those ones. Use fresh tomatoes and then drain them to get rid of all the excess water. This way, you will have a thicker sauce for your pizza.

how to thicken tomato sauce for pizza

Simmer the sauce longer

To thicken your tomato sauce, you can simmer it on low heat for a while. However, this might make the sauce less fresh. And when you cook the tomatoes too long, they won’t have as many vitamins in them. You can also add water to your tomato sauce if you want it to be thinner again.

If you’re in a hurry and need thick tomato sauce faster, put some tomatoes in a bread pan and spread them evenly over the pan’s surface. Keep the heat low so that they don’t burn or become too dry before cooking through.

Use other thickening ingredients

If you want to make your sauce thicker, add some starchy ingredients like pasta water, or mashed potatoes. But be careful because starchy ingredients put more calories on your dish and can make you gain weight.

Your other options are tomato paste, cornstarch, breadcrumbs, butter, and almond nuts.

How do you thicken watery pizza sauce?

There are a few things you can do. One is to simmer the sauce at low heat for a long time without affecting the flavor. Another is to add 1-2 tbsp of cornstarch or flour tempered with water.

How do you thicken pizza sauce without tomato paste?

Here are some ways that you can do it.

  • Add pasta water to your sauce. The liquid that cooks the pasta has a lot of starches in it.
  • Mix in some cornstarch.
  • Use flour and butter.
  • Add mashed potatoes to your sauce instead of tomato paste.
  • Simmer your sauce longer so it is thicker.

Can you use tomato sauce for pizza?

Sometimes people do. They can be made with plain tomato sauce or pureed tomatoes and tomato paste. This makes them thicker than pasta sauce, which prevents the dough from getting too soggy while it cooks.

Should pizza sauce be thick?

The consistency of pizza sauce is totally up to you. Tomato sauce can be thicker than regular tomato sauce, but not as thick as tomato puree. The more you reduce down the sauce, the stronger it will be.

Why is my pizza sauce watery?

Too much water from the tomatoes can make it watery. Add salt to taste and mix. If you want the taste of fresh tomatoes, try this pizza sauce!

What tomato sauce is good for pizza?

The ones made from tomatoes in San Marzano are definitely the best in my opinion. These are native to San Marzano, Italy, and are grown on the soils of Mt. Vesuvius.

Can pasta sauce be used for pizza?

Yes, but you will need to change the water. Then cook it longer. If there are large chunks in the pasta sauce, then put it in a food processor or blender.

What is the difference between tomato paste and pizza sauce?

Tomato paste is different from pizza sauce because the tomato flavor is more intense and thicker than tomato sauce. Tomato paste does not act as the main ‘tomato’ ingredient in a dish, but rather helps to add rich flavors.

What is the best sauce to put on pizza?

For people who like spices, the hot sauce may be a good choice. Ranch may also be a good choice for people who don’t like spicy things.

Do you cook pizza sauce?

Yes, take the sauce and put it in a pot. Cook it for at least half an hour, so that the taste is exactly how you want it. If you don’t cook the sauce, it tastes sour and raw.

Is pizza sauce thicker than marinara?

Pizza sauce is thicker than marinara. Marinara has a light consistency, while pizza sauce is thick. For making good marinara, you need to roast and blend onion, tomato, and basil.

Mariana Rouco

Mariana Rouco is the editor-in-chief of Elpasony.com. She loves traveling and writing about foods and cooking in general. She has a degree from the New England Culinary Institute and enjoys Mexican, Italian, and Chinese cuisines the most.

Recent Posts