Fire Roasted Tomatoes Substitute: Top 5 Best Choices

fire roasted tomatoes substitute

Fire-roasted tomatoes are a delicious and easy way to add flavor to many dishes.

However, they can be expensive and time-consuming to make. Luckily there’s an alternative that you can try at home.

And in today’s post, I will share with you some awesome ideas about how to substitute fire-roasted tomatoes.

Read more: Ginger Substitute

Best substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes you can try at home

fire roasted tomatoes substitute

Here are the top 5 best substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes you can use for your recipes:

Fresh tomatoes that are diced

You can use diced tomatoes as a substitute for fire-roasted ones. The diced ones do not have the smoky taste and smell that fire-roasted ones do, but they are still good and fresh.

Tomatoes are healthier when they are not cooked. They will have most of their nutrients, like lycopene. It’s a good idea to have a tomato plant in your house so you can always eat them!

For almost all your recipes, you can use diced tomatoes with ease. You can use them as a topping for soup, or in Mexican food like tacos and salsa.

The fruits can make a dish wet. But if you cook it, this won’t happen. If you want to store them, then they should be canned or frozen.

Canned tomatoes

Canned products are not a bad option here if you cannot afford fire-roasted ones.

They still have nutrients and vitamins and minerals like fresh ones do, but they also last longer. You can put them in your pantry and use them for later as long as they’re before their expiry date.

Canned tomatoes are easy to use for dishes. You can put them on pasta, soup, or even pizza!

One downside is that they are not as healthy as fresh fruits because of the preservatives in them.

If you were in an emergency situation, this option would still be a good option.

Sun-dried tomatoes

Sun-dried tomatoes are my favorite. Roasted ones are good too, but they’re really different.

They’re just ripe tomatoes that have gone through a process like drying in the sun and losing their water. People use this type of preservation since ancient times to make food last longer and protect it from getting spoiled or rotten.

Sun-dried ones are like other sun-dried fruits, except they are salty. They don’t taste smoky. They last longer than fire-roasted tomatoes because they have been through a food preservation process, but if you open the bag, you need to eat them within 6 months.

Tomato puree

Tomato puree is made from boiling and mashing tomatoes. If you don’t have an oven, make a puree now. You can also buy it in a can. But we think that if you want to make the best puree, it’s better to make it yourself.

It’s very nutritious, and you can make tomato puree when tomatoes are in season. You can add salt and pepper or chilies to taste. It usually lasts for 6 months in the freezer.

Tomato puree can be used in different dishes. It works best when making tomato soup, sauce, pasta, or pizza. You can also add it to beef or chicken stews if you want some extra flavor.

The puree is liquid so it does not have texture but this is okay because you can always add chunks of tomatoes if you need more texture.

Tomato paste

Tomato paste is a thick and concentrated red sauce. It looks like toothpaste but is in a tomato color. The seeds and skins have been removed so the texture is smooth.

Tomato pastes are not thin or watery because they have been cooked for a long time to remove the water from them. You can dissolve it in warm water or add it when you are cooking your dish, but make sure to measure it first because the flavor might be too strong for you.

If you use tomato paste, you will not be able to taste the difference. It still tastes like tomatoes and has color too. Tomato paste is cheaper than canned tomatoes. They are also easy to store and convenient for cooking with.

Tomato paste is good for dishes that are made with a lot of sauces. It can also be added to vegetable dishes to make them more flavorful.

I like using tomato paste when I am trying to cut down on calories because it adds flavor without adding too many calories.

Fire-roasted vs regular tomatoes, what are the differences?

The main difference is that the former is tomatoes that were cooked over a flame. This makes it sweet and smoky tasting.

What are fire-roasted tomatoes good for?

They are good for using with pasta sauce, soup, or chili. They are especially good in Mexican or Tex Mex food. You can also make them into salsa.

What do fire-roasted tomatoes have in them?

They have organic tomato juice, citric acid, sea salt, and chloride calcium.

Is their taste spicy?

Yes, they are spicy. They have a strong taste and people like to eat them with pasta or in salsa.

Can I substitute tomato sauce for fire-roasted tomatoes?

Yes, you can. If you have tomato sauce or paste, you can add it to the roasted red peppers. But if not, you can use spices to replace the flavors.

How do you make diced tomatoes taste like fire-roasted?

You need to pour olive oil over your tomatoes, then use salt, pepper to season them, then add other ingredients that you want. The roasted in an oven at 350 degrees F for around 1 hour and 15 minutes without stirring. (recipe)

What nutritions does a can of fire-roasted tomatoes have?

A can of this food (190g) often has 30 calories. It has 0% fat (0g). It has 9% sodium. It has 10% potassium. The carbohydrates are 6.6g.

Can you fire roast crushed tomatoes?

Fire-roasted crushed tomatoes are made from fresh whole fruits that have been roasted with open flame. This makes them really good for soups, sauces, and stews.

They provide a lot of Vitamin A and C as well as some iron.

Can you fire roast frozen tomatoes?

Put the fruits in a freezer bag and put them in the freezer. After they are frozen, take them out and put them with olive oil, basil, salt, and pepper on a cookie sheet. Put it in the oven for 40 minutes at 400 degrees Fahrenheit.

How many calories are in a fire-roasted tomato?

Around 30 calories per serving.

How to make canned tomatoes have a fire-roasted flavor?

Add olive oil, salt, and pepper, and add some other ingredients. Roast the tomatoes in your oven for 1 1/4 hours. (recipe)

Can I substitute diced tomatoes for fire-roasted tomatoes?

Yes, you can. You just need to add some smoked paprika into the mix.


In summary, here are the top 5 best substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes you can use for your recipes:

  • Fresh tomatoes that are diced
  • Canned tomatoes
  • Sun-dried tomatoes
  • Tomato puree
  • Tomato paste

If you have not tried any of these options in your recipes yet, it may be worth giving them a try.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts