What To Do With Leftover Sweet Potato Pie Filling?

what to do with leftover sweet potato pie filling

There are always so many leftovers from all of the amazing Holidays meals.

If you’re lucky enough to have leftover sweet potato pie filling, here are a few ideas on what you can do with it.

From pies to pancakes, these recipes will help you use up every last bit of that delicious sweet potato goodness.

Let’s take a look at them, shall we?

Make a sweet potato pie smoothie

Making a sweet potato pie smoothie with your leftover pie filling is a great way to enjoy it for breakfast, or as an afternoon snack.

I like to add almond milk and banana to my smoothies so they’re extra thick and creamy.

If you want your smoothie to be nice and cold, now’s the time to throw in some frozen fruit.

To do this, just blend your leftover filling with almond milk, the fruit of choice, and any other additions you might want.

I love adding a little bit of cinnamon for some added flavor.

Make sweet potato pie pancakes with maple syrup

If you’re looking for something that’s more on the savory side, then this is an awesome option for you.

All you have to do is mix together your leftover filling, an egg or two, some waffle batter of choice, and some maple syrup.

It’s super easy to make and tastes amazing.

I had these for breakfast with a fried egg on top along with some turkey bacon.

To complete the meal I added a side of sweet potato hashbrowns.

The pancakes were sweet and savory at the same time, and they satisfied my cravings for something that was a little bit more indulgent.

Add it to oatmeal

You can also try adding your sweet potato pie filling to your favorite overnight oatmeal recipe.

Either make some on the stovetop or just add it to your favorite premade jar for a quick and easy breakfast you can grab as you head out the door.

Mix it with brown sugar, cinnamon, and raisins for a quick dessert

This is another simple option you can try if you’re not in the mood for something super sweet.

Combine your leftover filling with some brown sugar, cinnamon, and raisins, then spoon it into a pie crust or roll it out like a sugar cookie, cut into small rectangles and enjoy.

Make an ice cream sundae

Next, you can always add your leftover pie filling to an ice cream sundae.

To do this, simply add some vanilla ice cream to a bowl and top with your pie filling, whipped cream, and pecans.

It can’t get any easier than that.

You can also try this with chocolate or caramel syrup for an added sweet touch.

Use it as a filling for crepes or turnovers

Another simple yet delicious option is to add your pie filling to a crepe or turnover recipe.

This is a great way to eat up leftover sweet potatoes, and you can add them to any of your favorite recipes.

You will need to add in some extra spices and maybe a little bit of sugar to the recipe depending on what type of filling you’re going for.

Bake it into cookies or muffins

To do this, simply add your leftover pie filling to a recipe that calls for pumpkin pie filling.

You can add it to your favorite cookie or muffin recipe, and if you need some ideas on what recipes to use check out this link.

Make a sweet potato cheesecake

You can always try making a quick lo-carb sweet potato cheesecake with your leftover filling.

I like to make this one because it’s super simple, quick, and tastes delicious.

To make your sweet potato cheesecake you will need the following ingredients:

  • 1 8oz package of low-fat cream cheese
  • 1/2 cup granulated Splenda (you can also use stevia instead)
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1 14oz can of sweet potatoes
  • 2 eggs
  • cinnamon and nutmeg to taste

To make a cheesecake you will need a springform pan or a pie pan.

Now, simply combine all of your ingredients in a bowl and mix together until smooth.

Then pour into your pan and sprinkle on some cinnamon and nutmeg to taste.

Bake at 350 degrees for one hour or until the center is firm.

How do you store leftover sweet potato pie filling?

what to do with leftover sweet potato pie filling

To store your leftover filling simply put it in a sealed container and place it in the fridge.

It should last for around one week depending on how fresh your sweet potatoes were when you first made them.

Can you leave sweet potato pie filling out overnight?

Although it is possible to leave the filling out overnight the best way to store it is in your fridge.

Leaving your filling out will make it more susceptible to bacteria growth, and therefore leaving your leftover filling sitting at room temperature overnight isn’t recommended. (source)

Can you freeze uncooked sweet potato pie filling?

Yes, it’s possible to freeze your leftover sweet potato filling.

This is a great option if you want to prepare the filling in advance and have it ready for whenever you need it.

When freezing, simply put it in a sealed container and place it in the freezer.

It should last for around three months when frozen correctly.

Can you use canned sweet potatoes in sweet potato pie filling?

To keep your sugar content low it is recommended that you use fresh ripe sweet potatoes when making your own homemade filling.

Canned sweet potatoes have a longer shelf life, but they also contain significantly more sugar. (source)

Do you eat sweet potato pie hot or cold?

This is totally up to you, and it also depends on what type of filling you’re eating.

If your dining hall serves the canned stuff I would recommend eating it cold since it has a longer shelf life that way.

However, if you’re making this from scratch at home I would recommend eating it warm accompanied by ice cream or whipped cream.

Do you have to cook sweet potato pie filling?

To make this delicious dish, you will need to boil your sweet potatoes until they are soft enough to blend in a food processor or blender.

Then simply add any other ingredients and mix them together. (source)

How long is homemade sweet potato pie good for?

Homemade one is good for around 3-4 days if stored in an airtight container in the fridge.

How do you defrost sweet potato pie filling?

In order to defrost your filling just place the sealed container into the fridge and wait until it’s been defrosted.

If you’re in a rush you can always run the container under warm water if you’re feeling impatient.

When should you eat sweet potato pie?

You can eat it at any time of day, making it a great study snack for your late-night study sessions.

It is especially good to have in the late afternoon or early evening when you need an energy boost.

Can you overcook sweet potato pie?

Although you shouldn’t overcook yours, having a crispy crust on top can be very appealing.

If this is your preference then simply cook the pie for 10 minutes longer than directed and you should be good to go.


There are so many delicious ways to enjoy your leftover sweet potato pie filling, you’re sure to find one that satisfies your cravings.

Whether you want something sweet or savory, my recipes above have got you covered.

So get creative and have fun with it – the possibilities are endless.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts