Tomato Substitute In Soup: Top 6 Best Choices to Try

tomato substitute in soup

A lot of people enjoy having tomatoes in their soup.

But what if someone can’t eat tomatoes?

Well, there are a few substitutes that might work in your recipe.

These substitutes also add flavor and nutrients to the soup.

If you’re looking for something that can replace tomatoes in this situation, then this post is for you.

Let’s check out some of the best tomato substitutes you can use for your soup.

Read more: What To Do With Leftover Apples?

Best tomato substitutes in soup

tomato substitute in soup

Pear juice

You can use pear juice as a base for tomato soup. Peel the pears out of the juice before you cook it. You might want to puree the pears too.

The benefits of pear juice are that it helps your body absorb nutrients better, makes your immune system stronger, reduces blood pressure, improves circulation, strengthens bones, and supports nervous system health.

It also reduces inflammation in your body and helps with cognitive skills like concentration and memory.

Sweet red peppers

Sweet red peppers can be a substitute for tomatoes in soups. They are a good source of vitamin C and other nutrients. Especially the ripest red ones.

They also have antioxidant properties, which may help protect against diseases such as cardiovascular disease and cancers.


Beets can be used to make soup with tomatoes. First, dice the beets very finely and cook them with onion, carrots, and celery.

Add some paprika and turmeric for color. Use cider vinegar to make the soup have a tart flavor as tomatoes do.

You could also roast the beets before blending them up with some broth for a smoother consistency like tomato sauce.

Any combination of savory and acid

Tomatoes are delicious because they have savory umami and acid.

To make soups, you can use combinations of foods that are high in acids like vinegar or lemon juice, or ingredients like cheese that are high in glutamates (which give the umami flavor).

You might need to make the recipe a few times before you find something that tastes good. I bet if you try, then it will be satisfying.

Sour plums

Sour plums are similar to tomatoes. They are used in many Middle Eastern dishes.

Plums are a type of fruit that is very healthy, with lots of vitamins and minerals. They may also help prevent chronic diseases like osteoporosis, cancer, heart disease, and diabetes.

There is little preparation required for plums – they can be eaten raw or cooked into dishes.


Nomato sauces are a good alternative to tomato sauce. They’re made from vegetables and seasonings and they don’t have soy, dairy, wheat, or gluten. I saw some reviews that said they were good.

Do tomatoes need to be peeled for soup?

You do not need to peel the tomatoes for soup. Tomato skins will give flavor to your soup. If you don’t want big pieces of skin in your bowl, cut the tomatoes into small pieces.

Why do you add tomato paste to soup?

Tomatoes are great to put in soup because they make it taste better. Tomato paste, which has a very strong flavor, is good for adding to sauces.

What goes well with tomatoes in soup?

You can eat it with these dishes: grilled cheese, bacon and pesto, Hawaiian grilled cheese, mozzarella sticks, BLT sandwich.

How can I make my tomato soup more flavorful?

One way to make your soup more flavorful is by roasting the tomatoes before adding them to the soup pot. You can also add herbs, spices, and other vegetables to the soup.

For a creamy soup, you can add some cream or cheese. If you want a heartier soup, you can add some meat or beans.

Can I make tomato soup with fresh tomatoes?

Yes, you can make tomato soup with fresh tomatoes.

You will need to blanch the tomatoes first, then add them to the soup pot. Blanching is the process of boiling vegetables for a short time, then shocking them in ice water. This preserves the color and flavor of the vegetables.

Should you use chicken or beef broth in tomato soup?

You can use either chicken or beef broth in tomato soup, depending on what you prefer.

If you want a richer flavor, then you might want to use beef broth. If you are looking for a lighter soup, then chicken broth might be a better choice.

How long should you cook tomato soup?

Tomato soup should be cooked for about 30 minutes, or until the vegetables are soft. You can also cook it longer if you want a richer flavor.

How do you cut the acidity in tomato soup?

You can neutralize the acidity in tomatoes by adding baking soda. The tomatoes will taste less acidic, and you can also put milk into this soup without risking curdling it.

How do you thicken tomato soup?

There are many ways to thicken it.

One way is to simmer the soup. You can also add tomato paste, or make a roux with flour and butter, or add cream, eggs, or starches like cornstarch.

Another common way is to add cheese, nuts, and bread crumbs.

Is tomato soup good for you?

It is good for you.

It has many antioxidants, including lycopene, flavonoids, and vitamins C and E. Eating these types of food can make you less likely to get cancer or inflammation-related diseases like heart disease or diabetes.

Do you have to add water to tomato soup?

No, you don’t need to add water. You can make it with butter, tomatoes, and onion.

First, you cook the tomatoes and onion until they are at a thick consistency. Then take out the onions and put the sauce on the pasta.

If you want soup, then just blend everything together before serving it up. It is genius and delicious!

Is cream of tomato soup the same as tomato soup?

It is a type of soup that has been cooked for a long time. Cream of tomato soup is made from pureed tomatoes, cream, and other ingredients. It’s then cooked again to make it taste better.

How do you cut tomato taste in soup?

To take the taste of tomatoes in soup away, add sugar. You can use natural honey, agave syrup, or sugar.

Can I use tomato paste instead of tomato soup?

It would taste good to use the paste instead of the soup because it is an important and close substitute for tomatoes when making this dish.

Is tomato soup filling?

It can be filling. It is creamy and fattening or lean and filling, depending on what you put in it. It can be a part of a healthy meal plan.

Having a cup of tomato soup with a salad at lunch or before dinner can help you lose weight.

Is tomato soup a soup?

Yes, it is. It has tomatoes as its primary ingredient. It can be served hot or cold, and it can have lots of different things in it.

Can you eat tomato soup by itself?

Yes, but most people usually eat it with bread.

Why do grilled cheese and tomato soup go together?

Some people think grilled cheese and tomato soup go together because they are both cheap. Others think that they go together because of how healthy it is.


In short, here are the 6 best substitutes for tomatoes in soups you can try:

  • Pear juice
  • Sweet red peppers
  • Beets
  • Any combination of savory and acid
  • Sour plums
  • Nomato

With these 6 substitutes, you’ll never have to worry about not having tomatoes on hand when making soup again. Give them a try and experience the difference they can make in your soups.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts