10 Tasty Ways to Use up Leftover Deviled Egg Filling

Proper storage for deviled eggs is vital because if they are not taken care of properly, they may spoil and you will lose the food that has been prepared.

It’s possible to keep them in a fridge for two days after eggs have been boiled and peeled, but then they must be kept in an airtight container and placed into the coldest part of the fridge.

The good news is that there are many ways leftover egg filling can be reused to make delicious meals or snacks.

And in this post, I will share with you some of my favorite ways to use the leftover deviled egg fillings.

Let’s check them out.

What to do with leftover deviled egg fillings?

Using your leftover egg filling is an easy way to erase the guilt you may feel when throwing out food because you didn’t consume it fast enough.

It’s relatively inexpensive, so it tends to get wasted often, but this doesn’t have to be the case.

Whatever part of the filling you have leftover can be creatively reused in order to save money and eat healthy meals without spending hours in the kitchen cooking up something new.

Here are some great suggestions that you can try for yourself:

1. Use it as a spread on slices of bread or crackers with other tasty toppings like sliced olives or onions.

2. Mix it with sour cream, lots of black pepper, and some salt to make a yummy dip for your veggies or chips.

3. Replace the mayonnaise called for in any recipe you are making by using the leftover egg mixture instead. This can help lower fat content without significantly changing the flavor of your dish.

4. Spread it on top of sandwiches that use pita bread or tortillas as buns. It will give them an extra kick that most sandwich recipes don’t have!

5. Add milk, hot sauce, garlic powder, paprika, onion powder, and pepper together to create a spread that can be used on bread or crackers just like with leftovers from boiled eggs without the filling.

6. Fold it into mashed potatoes for a more flavorful side dish that will be enjoyed by all.

7. Mix in some cooked vegetables or boiled meat to make a fantastic egg salad with lots of whole ingredients instead of just the egg mixture on its own.

It’s always best to enjoy deviled eggs when they are fresh, but if you have any leftover egg filling it can be used in many different ways.

It’s even better to use the egg mixture instead of just throwing it out because then you don’t have to feel bad about wasting food.

The only thing that should be thrown away after deviling eggs is the shells once they have been rinsed off and stored properly for less than three days.

Use the information presented here to help you learn how this tasty dish made from simple ingredients can become something bigger to enjoy later on with friends or family members.

What do you put in the middle of the deviled egg tray?

When you are making a big appetizer platter, you can put the deviled egg tray in the center.

Then you can use kale or lettuce as a garnish to make it look pretty.

And then put cheese or cold cuts around the eggs.

What do deviled eggs contain?

Deviled eggs are eggs that are boiled hard.

Their yolks are often mixed with mustard, mayonnaise, salt, vinegar, and pepper.

Paprika is often put on top as a finishing touch.

How do you make deviled egg fillings thicker?

Add an egg yolk to the mixture.

This will make them thicker.

You can also add xanthan gum, instant mashed potatoes, or bread crumbs.

What is the center of a deviled egg called?

The yolk in the center of a deviled egg is called the “crown.”

This is because it’s the part that is cut off and eaten as the appetizer.

The yolk is also where you’ll find most of the fat, making it the perfect base for a creamy filling.

Classic deviled egg fillings usually involve combining crumbly yellow yolks with mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, salt, distilled white vinegar, and pepper.

Can you boil eggs the day before you make deviled eggs?

Yes, you can boil eggs the day before.

Boil them for up to 48 hours.

Then peel them and cut them in half.

Take out the yolk that is inside.

Cover it with plastic wrap, and put it in the fridge until just before you are ready to serve it.

Take out your egg whites which you have stored in your fridge, and mix with the yolk mixture again just before serving.

Why is it called a deviled egg?

Deviled eggs are so-called because they are spicy, or have a lot of condiments.

They come from the 18th century when fried or boiled dishes with a lot of spices were called “deviled”.

Today, it means any dish that has sauce in it.

What’s the difference between deviled eggs and Angel eggs?

Deviled eggs are eggs that you boil first.

They’re mixed with spices like cayenne pepper to make them hotter, and then the mix is put back into the egg whites.

Angel eggs are made by stirring cream cheese into boiled eggs, not cooking them first.

How do I keep my deviled eggs from getting watery?

When you cook the eggs, make sure that they are cooked for a long time (at least 10 minutes).

It can be hard to decide how long to cook them.

You want them to be cooked enough so the yolks are set but not too much so they will get watery.

What happens if you put too much mayo in deviled eggs?

If you put too much mayonnaise in your deviled eggs, they will be too creamy and will not hold their shape.

How do you make deviled eggs not wet?

The eggs will be wet if you put them in hot water instantly.

To make the eggs not wet, cover them with cold water first then boil the water up.

How do you fix deviled eggs with too much salt?

Too much salt makes deviled eggs taste bad.

If you put a lot of sweet pickles in the egg, it will make the eggs taste better.

You can also add garlic, horseradish, or curry to make it taste better.

What’s the best way to keep deviled eggs cold for a picnic?

Deviled eggs need to be cold at a picnic.

You can store them in muffin tins with foil wrapped around it.


To summarize, there are many ways to use up your leftover deviled eggs fillings.

Consider the ideas I shared above for inspiration and you’ll be able to find a new favorite dish in no time.

More From Elpasony

Tapas Tales: Embark on a Flavor-Filled Spanish Adventure

19 Easy and Healthy Toddler Snacks You Haven’t Tried Yet

Indulge Your Culinary Wanderlust: 15 Foodie Paradises for Every Palate

The post 10 Tasty Ways to Use up Leftover Deviled Egg Filling first appeared on elpasoNY.com.

Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Brent Hofacker.

For transparency, this content was partly developed with AI assistance and carefully curated by an experienced editor to be informative and ensure accuracy.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts