Should You Add Sugar to Pizza Sauce?

should you add sugar to pizza sauce

Pizza is a quintessential American food, and it’s no surprise that many people enjoy the occasional slice.

But what about those who want to take pizza to a whole new level? We’re talking homemade sauce from scratch, fresh mozzarella cheese, and freshly grated parmesan.

If you find yourself in this camp, one question may have been nagging at you: should I add sugar to my pizza sauce?

In this blog post, we’ll find the answer to that question for you.

Should you add sugar to pizza sauce?

Most of the time. no. You shouldn’t add sugar to your pizza sauce. The best way for it is it should be cooked and simmered for at least 30 minutes. This will help the flavors meld and the sour tomato taste go away.

should you add sugar to pizza sauce

If you really don’t want to make it less sweet, try adding a little bit of sugar.

Or even better, try something other than sugar.

Since sugar is not a good kind of sweet, and it also only has calories that aren’t helpful at all to your pizza sauce. You can get a sweeter one by adding the following to it.

Butternut squash

You can make sweet pizza sauces with butternut squash. One way to do it is to roast the butternut squash beforehand and then use some for the sauce and freeze the rest for pumpkin pie.


Carrots are sweet vegetables. If you don’t want to see them in the mixture, chop them up or grate them. They will dissolve into small pieces when everything is done simmering and will add a good flavor to it.


They might smell, but they will make your recipe taste good. If you want to, you can cook a large batch and freeze it.

Or you can store it in small containers in the freezer. For the sweetest result, use yellow or white onions with a 1:1 ratio of onions and tomatoes.

Sweet potato

Sweet potatoes make better pizza sauces. Roasted and mashed sweet potatoes will make your recipe taste more like a dessert. The sweet potato will also keep it from getting too runny, but not as much as regular potatoes would.

How much sugar is in Heinz tomato sauce?

There are 20 calories and 160 mg sodium. There are also 4 grams of sugar.

How do you sweeten a sauce without sugar?

You can use cinnamon, bananas, or date to make your mixture taste better. You could also use shredded coconut, crushed berries, or apple sauce. Some people like to use vanilla extract. One last thing is sweet potatoes.

Is there added sugar in tomato sauce?

Some brands put sugar in their tomato-based sauces. Brands may use different amounts of added sugars, but usually, it is 3 grams (almost a teaspoon) to 12 grams (3 teaspoons) for a half-cup serving.

What can replace sugar in spaghetti sauce?

You can put grated carrots instead of sugar for a sweet taste. Or try the above-mentioned solutions.

Does sugar reduce acidity in tomato sauce?

Sugar can make everything a bit more balanced. The acidity level changes a lot depending on what type of tomatoes you use and when they are from.

How much sugar should be added to tomato sauce?

It can have sugar in it, but not too much. And only add sugar if you have to.

Add 1 teaspoon of sugar at a time and stir after each addition. I usually find that this is enough for me, but you can add more if you want. You can also season with salt and pepper if desired.

Do chefs put sugar in spaghetti sauce?

Yes, some chefs do that. But the amount of sugar is not very much. Sugar makes tomato sauce less acidic. It also adds another layer of flavor to it. The sweetness isn’t really strong either so it’s not too sweet like desserts are.

Does Prego make a sugar-free sauce?

Prego has a new product that does not have any sugar. It tastes the same as the others but does not have added sugar. You can use it on its own or use it as a base for your own homemade one.

Does pasta sauce have added sugar?

Some pasta sauces have sugar in them, but some don’t. If you put too much sugar in it can be bad for your health.

Can you put sugar in tomato sauce?

At the end of cooking, taste your sauce. If it is too acidic, you can add sugar to taste.


The pizza sauce recipe that you may have grown up with contains sugar, but this is not necessary. Try adding other sweet-tasting foods like the ones above to get the same effect without all of the calories.

You can also experiment by substituting out any sugars for different spices and herbs such as cinnamon, oregano, thyme, basil, cilantro—the list goes on.

This will give your sauces a new flavor profile while still giving them sweetness that makes kids happy.

What are some alternative ways to use sugar in homemade pizza sauce?

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts