Potato Substitute For Pot Roast: What Should You Use?

potato substitute for pot roast

When you’re making pot roast, what can you substitute for the potatoes?

There are a few different options, and each one has its own benefits.

Here’s a look at some different substitutes for potatoes in pot roast that you can actually use.

Let’s check them out.

Read more: What To Do With Leftover Kombu?


You can substitute carrots for potatoes when making pot roast.

The carrots will add a touch of sweetness to the dish and help thicken the sauce.

If you use this substitute, be sure to cut them into medium chunks (about 1-inch) so they don’t disintegrate while cooking in the crockpot.

Also, you can use baby carrots if you don’t want to have to cut up a lot of whole carrots.


Celery is another possible substitute for potatoes when making pot roasts.

Celery has a similarly light flavor to potatoes but with a bit more crunch than potatoes when cooked.

You can use chopped celery for this substitute, but if you want to experiment with flavor, try using the heart of the celery or using some leaves.

Those parts of celery are often overlooked in cooking, so they’re good options for trying something new in your recipes.


Some people like to use rutabaga in place of potatoes in their pot roasts.

Like carrots and celery, this root vegetable will add a touch of sweetness, which is a good way to balance out the flavors in your pot roast.

Rutabaga is generally available peeled and cubed, so it’s easy to use in recipes like this one when you don’t want to spend a lot of time cutting up vegetables.

Butternut squash

Butternut squash is another good option for when you want to avoid potatoes when making pot roast.

It will be naturally sweet when added to the dish, and it’s easy to use because it’s already peeled and cubed.

Just make sure you cut it in fairly large chunks so they don’t disintegrate in the crockpot.


Mushrooms can be a good choice for when you want to make a gluten-free or vegan pot roast without potatoes.

You can use any mushrooms you like, but if you go with fresh mushrooms, it might take a little more time to prepare them for this recipe because they have to be chopped.

Dried and canned mushrooms are already prepared, so you can use those if you’re short on time.


You may not always think to use corn in pot roast recipes, but it’s a great option when you want to sneak some vegetables into your dinner without changing the pot roast too much.

The kernels will soften up while cooking and give the dish its typical sweetness.

Try using fresh, frozen, or canned corn in your pot roast if you don’t want to cut up a fresh ear of corn.

Sweet potato

One of the biggest benefits of cooking with sweet potatoes is that you don’t have to do much prep work before adding them to your pot roast.

Whether you use fresh, frozen, or canned sweet potatoes, they’ll soften up while cooking and provide a nice sweetness to the dish.

What type of potatoes do you use for a roast?

You should use starchy potatoes when making a roast.

Some good ones include russets, golds, and whites.

These potatoes will give your dish the right texture and flavor without adding too many extra ingredients that may change the overall taste of your pot roast.

When should potatoes be added to the crockpot roast?

potato substitute for pot roast

You should wait to add potatoes until at least an hour before you want to eat.

They need this much time in the crockpot so they can cook all the way through and become soft.

You also want them to be able to absorb some of the flavors from the broth, which will only happen if they’re cooked for a while.

Are red or white potatoes better for roasting?

Red potatoes are a decent choice when you want to have a classic roast.

These potatoes are generally larger than white potatoes, so they’ll hold up better when they’re being cooked in the broth.

They also have more of a starchy texture that will give your roast the right consistency without adding too many extra ingredients or taking away from what makes pot roast so tasty. (source)

How to know if my roasted potatoes are done?

Pot roast is cooked until the beef falls apart easily.

It will typically take at least six hours for this to happen, but some crockpots may cook it a little faster or slower depending on their size and setting.

You can use a meat thermometer to test whether your roast is done.

The temperature should be at least 140 degrees Fahrenheit.

Do potatoes absorb bad flavors?

Potatoes are great for absorbing flavors, so that’s why it’s best to add them later in the cooking process rather than sooner.

This way you can give your roast as much flavor as possible without worrying about the potatoes taking on the negative aspects of certain ingredients that may be added before the potatoes are ready. (source)

When should I add my vegetables to a roast?

You’ll want to wait until your roast is almost done cooking before adding your vegetables.

You can take out the beef and cut it up, or just shred it so you can put it back in the pot with the veggies and broth once they’re ready.

You can also cook the vegetables separately and add them directly to the pot roast if you want a simpler dish without too many ingredients.

Are baking potatoes OK for roasting?

Baking potatoes are a fine choice for roasting, but you may want to use a starchy potato instead.

Baking potatoes aren’t as starchy and won’t be able to absorb all of the flavors from your roast the same way that a more traditional potato will. (source)

Should I add salt to my roast?

You’ll need plenty of salt to create the right flavors in your pot roast.

You can add it before cooking, during cooking, or after you’re done cooking.

It’s up to you, but you should try all of these methods if possible so you can see which one will give your roast the best overall taste.

Are Charlotte potatoes good for roasting?

Yes, Charlotte potatoes are a great choice when you’re looking for the perfect potato to go with your roast.

They’re actually grown specifically for this purpose, which is why they’re such an optimal ingredient when it comes to cooking up a pot roast that everyone in the family will love.

Why are my roast potatoes not crispy?

The key to crispy roast potatoes is removing them from the crockpot and letting them cook in your oven for a few minutes.

You can also use a deep fryer or pan-fry your potatoes if you prefer, so don’t be afraid to get creative when it comes to achieving the perfect crunch for your dish.

Can I parboil potatoes and roast them later?

Yes, you can parboil potatoes and roast them later.

It’s best to cut your potatoes up first since they’re less likely to fall apart if you don’t boil them whole.

The other advantage of boiling the potatoes before roasting them is that it reduces how long you have to cook them in the oven or crockpot.

Potato substitute for pot roast – Conclusion

There are a few different substitutes for potatoes that you can use when making pot roast.

Each one has its own benefits, and it’s up to you to decide which one will work best in your recipe.

try out a few of these substitutes to see which ones you like the best.

You may find that you prefer one over the others, or you may like mixing and matching them depending on what you’re in the mood for.

No matter what, though, you’ll have a delicious pot roast with plenty of flavors.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts