Milk Substitute For Jello Pudding: What Should You Use?

milk substitute for jello pudding

Do you love Jello pudding but want to avoid consuming dairy?

If so, you’ll be happy to know that there is a delicious and healthy milk substitute that can be used to make Jello pudding.

In this blog post, I will share with you my favorite milk substitute for Jello pudding.

So go ahead and enjoy your favorite dessert without any guilt.

Let’s get started.

What’s the best milk substitute for Jello pudding?

In my experience, the best milk substitute for Jello pudding is oat milk.

And for a good final result, you should try substituting between these two using a 1:1 ratio.

Oats are good for you because they are healthy.

They help you by giving your body fiber, vitamins, protein, and minerals.

Oats have been linked to a reduced risk of heart disease. (source)

This is because beta-glucan, which is a type of fiber, can help control cholesterol levels and blood sugar.

This fiber has prebiotics in it.

These are good for your gut because they help friendly bacteria live and grow.

Eating foods with this fiber such as oats has also been linked to improved immunity and gut health as well.

Strong reasons to try this substitute today, right?

Can I use whole milk in Jello pudding?

Yes, you can use whole milk in Jello pudding.

You just have to pick one flavor that you want.

The pudding will be different if you use skim milk or not. (source)

How much milk do you put in Jello pudding?

It depends on the recipe.

Usually, you need to mix 2 cups of milk with your mix and beat for 2 minutes.

Then pour into dessert dishes and then refrigerate until ready to serve.

What kind of milk do you use for Jello pudding?

Non-dairy milks are good for making pudding.

You can make it with almond, rice, cashew, or coconut milk.

My favorite is oat milk for sure.

Can you make Jello pudding with water instead of milk?

Yes, you can use water instead of milk.

If you don’t have any other types of milk or if you need to make a lot of pudding, then use a 3:4 ratio.

Can you make Jello Pudding without milk?

Yes, you can make Jello Pudding without milk.

This is a good way to make some easy and delicious dessert.

You can use almond milk, or other non-dairy milk, to make the pudding with.

Then it will taste good by itself.

milk substitute for jello pudding

Why is my Jello instant pudding lumpy?

Jello instant pudding can be lumpy because it wasn’t mixed properly.

A whisk or an electric mixer should have fixed that.

Can you substitute milk for water in Jello?

Jello can be made with milk instead of water.

It provides a cloudy look and taste.

It is great for adding creaminess and flavor to your jello layers, or even for changing the colors.

Can you use Lactaid milk in Jello pudding?

Yes, you can use Lactaid milk in Jello pudding.

Lactaid is a simple product because the exchange is 1 to 1.

That means that for every cup of milk you use, you need to use a cup of Lactaid as well.

You will only need 4 ingredients: pudding mix and some strawberries and graham cracker crusts.

How do you thicken Jello pudding that won’t set?

You should add another packet of instant pudding mix.

Then it will be thick.

Do people eat Jello with milk?

Yes, but make sure you follow these steps.

First, make sure your cool whip is soft and fully thawed.

Add the warm milk mixture to the mixer on medium speed.

Then pour half of your cream into the baking dish after adding in some dissolved jello.

Is Jello healthy?

No, Jello is not that healthy.

It has a lot of sugar and it is low in fiber and protein.

A serving of sugar-free jello made with aspartame only has 1 gram of protein, 13 calories, but still there might be a negative effect on your health from artificial sweeteners. (source)

How can I quickly harden jello?

You can make Jello set faster if you put ice in the cold water.

Then stir it into the gelatin mix until it’s slightly thickened.

Remove any unmelted ice, and then refrigerate for 30 to 90 minutes before eating.

Can I add gelatin to pudding?

Yes, you can.

You should use 3/4 teaspoon of gelatin (unflavored type) for one milk cup or cream in your pudding.

This will set the pudding without creating a rubbery texture like gelatin would usually do. (source)

Can I use 1% milk to make pudding?

Yes, you can.

The pudding made with skim milk was not as good as the pudding made with whole or 1% milk.

You can try it if you want, but it won’t be very good. (source)


Jello pudding is a classic dessert that many people enjoy.

But if you need to avoid dairy, it can be hard to find milk substitutes for this recipe.

I’ve found the best substitute in my experience is oat milk because of its neutral flavor and consistency.

To get the perfect result with this substitution though, I recommend using 1 part oat milk for every one part cow’s or soy milk called for in your recipe.

Hopefully these tips will help you make delicious vegan desserts.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts