Milk Substitute For Muffins: What Should You Use?

milk substitute for muffins

Muffins are a delicious breakfast or snack.

But what happens when you’re out of milk and need a substitute?

Do you have any other options?

In this blog post, I will share with you my favorite choice when it comes to substituting dairy milk while making muffins.

Let’s get started.

What’s the best milk substitute for muffins?

In my experience, rice milk is the best milk substitute for muffins.

You can start swapping between these two with a 1:1 ratio, or you can adjust the ratio based on your own recipe.

People make rice milk by pressing the grains of rice through a mill.

Then it is strained and blended with water.

You can also add sweeteners to it and have more nutrients in the milk.

If you want the DIY route, you will need to use rice flour or boil rice, blend it with water, and strain it to create the final product.

The downside is that homemade rice milk won’t have as many nutrients as store-bought milk.

Rice milk is good for people with allergies because it’s less allergenic than other plant milk.

Rice milk also has carbs and little fat, so it’s good for athletes to give them energy. (source)

What does adding milk to muffins do?

Adding milk to muffins can improve the tenderness of the crumb.

It also improves the strength and structure of the muffin.

Milk is used in some recipes for yeast dough because it is a liquid ingredient. (source)

Are muffins better with water or milk?

No, milk can actually make holes in the paper liners or the sides of the muffin.

Professionals recommend using water instead of milk. (source)

What is the secret to making moist muffins?

The secret to moist muffins is to use both oil and butter.

This will make them taste good and be soft.

Do not mix the batter more than 12 times, and do not bake them for longer than 20 minutes.

What kind of milk do you use for muffins?

Whole milk with 3.25% fat is the type of milk I often use.

Can you use milk instead of water to bake muffins?

You can use milk instead of water to bake muffins if you want.

But it is not recommended because the muffins will be too moist and will not cook right.

If your box mix calls for water, it’s probably because adding milk will make them too moist.

Do you have to use milk for muffins?

No, you don’t have to.

But milk does help the leavening ingredients in the muffins a bit.

It can make your muffins light and fluffy.

Can you substitute applesauce for milk in muffins?

Yes, and you need to measure the same amount of applesauce that the recipe wanted for water or milk. (source)

How do you make muffins fluffier?

milk substitute for muffins

To make muffins fluffier, you need to use eggs, milk, and butter at room temperature.

This will help the mixture form a smooth texture and it will trap air and expand when heated in your oven.

The expansion makes your muffins fluffy and light. (source)

Are muffins better with oil or butter?

A muffin is better with butter than oil.

Butter has milk and fat, which makes the muffin tastier and richer.

Using butter does not mean that you cannot use oil.

What ingredient makes muffins rise?

The main ingredient that makes muffins rise is carbon dioxide bubbles.

Chemicals like baking powder and baking soda produce them.

When liquid and heat react with baking powder, bubbles will form.

With acids and baking soda, bubbles will form as well.

How do you upgrade muffin mix?

To make your store-bought muffin mix better, you can add fruit to it.

You can also chop up some nuts or put some chocolate chips in them.

To add fruit, you would take a handful of berries or diced apples and put them into the batter. (source)

Why didn’t my muffins rise?

Muffins won’t rise if you use a lot of baking powder or baking soda.

Also, your oven might not be at the proper heat level.

And if you undermix the batter, it’s likely that your muffins won’t develop much structure. (source)

What happens if you add an extra egg to muffins?

If you add an extra egg to muffins, the batter will hold more liquid and sugar.

This makes a moister and sweeter cake that is still good after it bakes. (source)

Do you need oil in muffins?

Well, it’s best to put some in because the oil will make the muffin moist.

It will also make them a lot better. (source)

Why are my muffins dry and dense?

You might have put too much leavening in the muffin batter.

There should be less baking powder or baking soda for every cup of flour.

Which oil is best for muffins?

You should use vegetable oil because it doesn’t have a strong taste.

I usually put 1½ teaspoon of vegetable oil into 12 muffins.

Melted butter, on the other hand, naturally hardens when the muffins are cooled.

Why are my muffins hard on top?

If you cook the muffins for too long, they will have a hard crust.

You can tell if they are done by sticking a pick in the center of the muffin when it is in the oven.


In my experience, rice milk is the best substitute for regular dairy in muffins.

You can start swapping between these two with a 1:1 ratio, or you can adjust the ratio based on your own recipe.

If you’re looking to create a vegan dish that mimics what cream cheese does in a traditional cheesecake, this alternative may be perfect for you.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts