What To Do With Leftover Fudge?

what to do with leftover fudge

What do you do with leftover fudge?

I have a little bit of fudge that I want to use up but don’t know how to reheat it or if it will even be good.

Maybe you’re making some homemade chocolate fudge as a special treat, and now you have leftover fudge.

Or maybe someone gave you a pan of store-bought fudge as a gift, and you’d rather not eat twelve pieces of it yourself.

So what do you do with leftover fudge?

You might be surprised to find out just how versatile this dessert is in terms of cold-weather dishes.

And one thing’s for sure – nobody will blame you for eating the delicious treat all by itself, straight from the container.

But to get the most out of your leftover fudge, consider these suggestions.

Use in savory dishes

Fudge is so delicious by itself, but it can also be used in savory recipes like beef stew and chicken pot pie.

This mixture of flavors might seem strange at first, but it may surprise you just how well they go together.

The rich chocolate flavor contrasts nicely with the heartier ingredients of the main dish.

Try adding pieces of leftover fudge to a hearty autumn soup, or place some under chicken breasts before baking for an amazing main course.

Use it for ice cream toppings

Fudge also makes a deliciously different ice cream topping – drizzle some on top of brownies or other pastry desserts for personal sundaes any time you wish.

Your family will love this special treat.

How about some s’mores?

You can also use leftover chocolate fudge to make decadent s’mores.

Just replace the graham crackers with chocolate-dipped marshmallows, and enjoy.

Just don’t put it directly on the fire, even if it’s wrapped in foil.

It’s actually possible to burn marshmallows that way, and your extra chocolatey treat will turn into a big burned mess instead of an amazing dessert.

You can always leave some unmelted marshmallow inside for added flavor, though.

[embedyt] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDh68qACyw8[/embedyt]

Just freeze it

If you’re afraid your fudge might go bad before you get a chance to eat it all (although we know that won’t be much of a problem.), consider freezing any leftovers.

This will make it last longer, although you will have to wait for the treat to thaw before enjoying it again.

And that’s not a problem at all.

This way, your family can enjoy homemade fudge for months after the holidays are over.

What can I do with flopped fudge?

If your fudge is soft, scrape it back into a large saucepan and add 1.5 cups of water.

Stir the fudge over low heat until it dissolves.

If your fudge is hard, add 1.5 cups of water to the saucepan and stir the fudge over low heat until it dissolves.

Taste the mixture to see if the flavor was diluted by the water. (source)

Can fudge be melted down?

Yes, fudge can be melted.

But it does not melt until it gets to about 125 degrees.

If you leave it in the sun, it will get soft but not melt like a candy bar would melt.

How do you soften hard fudge?

To make fudge softer, put it in a bag with bread.

Then seal it up tight and wait 10 hours.

Can you melt fudge to remake?


If your batch of fudge doesn’t set properly or it comes out hard, brittle, or overly grainy, you can melt it and remake it.

Put it back in a big, heavy-bottomed saucepan.

Then heat it over low heat until it is dissolved. (source)

How long does fudge stay good in the fridge?

You can keep it for 2 or 3 weeks.

It is best to keep your fudge in the fridge this way. (source)

How do you store fudge long term?

You can store your fudge by wrapping it in airtight containers like Tupperware, Saran wrap, or just vacuum seal it.

If you want to eat the fudge later, just take it out of the freezer a couple of hours before and let it thaw on your counter.

Why did my fudge turn out so dry?

what to do with leftover fudge

Your fudge turned out dry because you overcooked it, it became overly crystallized, or you beat it too much at the wrong temperature.

It can also turn tough if you are too careless when cooling it down.

What can I do with fudge that didn’t harden?

In that case, you need to cook it longer or to a higher temperature.

Why has my fudge turned to toffee?

The reason your fudge turned to toffee is that you didn’t cook it at a high enough temperature.

If the temperature is lower than 232 F, the fudge will be chewy and extra moist.

If the temperature is 234 F or higher, the fudge will be dry, hard, and crumbly. (source)

Why has my fudge turned to caramel?

When fudge turns to caramel, it is because the temperature is wrong.

The best temperature for cooking fudge is 232-234°F (111-112°C).

Everything else will change the texture of your fudge.

What is the secret to making fudge?

To make fudge, you must use a pan that heats up well.

That way it will not stick to the pan during cooking.

Brush the sides of the pan with water at the beginning of cooking to dissolve sugar crystals that are stuck to it.

Never stir during cooking or sugar could crystallize again.

How do you cool fudge?

The best way to cool fudge is to put it on a marble slab.

The slab will let the fudge cool evenly and quickly. (source)

Can you make fudge on a rainy day?

No, do not make fudge on humid or rainy days.

It can start to absorb water from the air.

Can you fix fudge that is too soft?

Yes, there are a few solutions you can try.

One option is to add powdered sugar.

This will help the fudge set and harden if it is resistant to doing so.

Another option is to add a mixture of water and cornstarch.


The best part about the fudge is that it can be used for a variety of purposes.

It would make an excellent holiday gift and could even be sent to your relatives overseas if you want to show them some love this season.

Or use it as a topping on ice cream or in place of frosting on cookies.

Get creative with what you do with the leftover fudge – there’s no wrong way to enjoy it.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts