Milk Substitute For Yorkshire Pudding: What Can You Use?

milk substitute for yorkshire pudding

You know what?

If you’re like me and grew up in a household where Yorkshire pudding was always on the Sunday dinner menu, you know that there’s nothing quite like it.

But what do you do if you can’t have milk?

Or someone in the family just doesn’t like it.

In this blog post, I’ll share with you my personal favorite milk substitute for using in Yorkshire pudding.

Now, let’s take a look.

What’s the best milk substitute for Yorkshire puddings?

In my experience, it’s best to use oat milk to substitute regular milk when baking these puddings.

You can start experimenting with a 1:1 ratio or adjust it based on your own needs and wants.

Oat milk is becoming very popular around the world.

It is good for people who are allergic to dairy.

You can try making oat milk at home if you want it to taste different than what you can find in stores.

However, I don’t recommend that route.

Oat milk is not as healthy as whole oats.

Commercial oat milk often has more nutrients in it, like potassium, calcium, iron, vitamins A, B vitamins, and vitamin D.

Oat milk may have more carbs, calories, and fiber than soy or almond milk.

It has less protein than soy or dairy milk. (source)

What is the best milk to use for Yorkshire puddings?

Full-fat milk is the best, and plain flour instead of self-raising.

To avoid lumps, gradually mix half the milk into the eggs and flour.

Beat it until it is smooth; then add the rest of the milk. (source)

What is the trick to Yorkshire pudding?

You need a hot tin and hot fat.

Pour the batter into the fat and it will start cooking right away.

This will result in higher, crispier puddings. (source)

What causes Yorkshire puddings not to rise?

Yorkshire puddings don’t rise if you put too much batter in the tins.

Fill the tins only about 1/3 full to make sure that they will rise.

What ingredient makes Yorkshire pudding rise?

It’s the eggs.

But remember to use equal amounts of milk, eggs, and flour.

If you use too much flour, the pudding will be dense.

Without enough eggs, there won’t be enough air for a good rise.

Too much milk will make the batter too loose. (source)

What happens if you use self-raising flour for Yorkshire puddings?

You can’t use self-raising flour for Yorkshire puddings.

If you use that, the puddings won’t rise up in the right way.

They just don’t work.

Do you put Yorkshire pudding batter in the fridge?

Yes, sometimes.

The batter should be cold and it is often made ahead of time.

The pan with drippings from roasting meat should be hot when you add the batter to it and then place that pan into an oven to cook.

This is because if your batter isn’t cold and if the pan with drippings isn’t hot, your puddings won’t rise as much. (source)

milk substitute for yorkshire pudding

Does olive oil work for Yorkshire puddings?

Yes, it does.

You can make Yorkshire puddings that will be tall and light with a lot of flavors.

Use either goose fat or dripping but also olive oil. (source)

How do you make Yorkshire puddings rise higher?

It is important to leave the batter for a while before baking.

The better flavor will come out.

You don’t need to worry about the cold batter, just let it rest at room temperature.

It will make the Yorkshire puddings taller and more crispy when they are done cooking.

What is the difference between a Dutch baby and Yorkshire pudding?

There are a few differences between a Dutch baby and a Yorkshire pudding.

The Yorkshire pudding is baked in individual servings that are greased with beef fat.

The Dutch baby is larger, uses butter instead of beef fat, and can be sweet. (source)

Why do my Yorkshire puddings sink when I take them out of the oven?

It could be because your oven was not hot enough, or because the oil was not hot enough when you put the batter in.

Or maybe you didn’t cook them long enough.

What is the difference between popovers and Yorkshire pudding?

Popovers are light and fluffy.

You can make them ahead of time, or just before the roast is done.

Yorkshires use beef fat that drips out of roasted beef.

Can you add baking powder to the Yorkshire pudding mix?


Add flour, baking powder, and salt into a bowl.

Make a well in the center.

Add eggs and milk.

Whisk the liquid, gradually incorporating the flour until smooth.

Pour in water and whisk until smooth.

Why do my Yorkshire puddings look like balls?

The batter needs to be cold before you use it, so you need to put it in the fridge for a while.

If the batter is not cold, it will look like balls when they are baked.

Some people say that chilling the batter isn’t necessary, but then they like their Yorkshire puddings without air inside them.

Why is my Yorkshire pudding flat?

The heat is not enough here.

The oven needs to stay at 220C/425F.

And you cannot open the door to the oven for a long time.


In summary, oat milk can be used to substitute regular milk in all types of baking, from puddings and pies to cookies or cakes.

Experiment with a 1:1 ratio or adjust it based on your own needs and wants.

In my experience, the best way is by using oat milk instead of dairy when making these recipes because it gives them a unique taste without affecting their texture too much.

If you find yourself looking for an alternative that won’t make your recipe turn out differently than what you were going for, try experimenting with oatmeal.

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts