Milk Substitute For Frosting: What Should You Use?

milk substitute for frosting

When it comes to frosting, there are many different ways to make it.

Some recipes call for milk, while others do not.

If you’re looking for a substitute for milk in your frosting recipe, what should you use?

There are several options that can work well.

But in this post, I will share with you my favorite one that can replace dairy milk when making frosting.

Read on to learn more about it.

What’s the best milk substitute for frosting?

After experimenting with some great options, I finally settle for coconut milk as the best substitute for cow milk in my frosting.

I used a 1:1 substitution ratio in my recipes, but you can surely adjust the ratio based on your own preferences.

When a recipe needs whole milk, you can use full-fat canned coconut milk.

When it needs heavy cream, you can use full-fat canned coconut cream or full-fat canned coconut milk.

If you want to make a recipe with lower-fat milk, you can use light coconut milk.

But if the recipe calls for skim milk, do not use coconut milk because it is fat-free and cannot be used in recipes that call for skim milk. (source)

What is the difference between icing and frosting?

Icing is a type of topping.

It is not as thick as frosting, but thicker than a glaze.

Icing is made from powdered sugar and liquid, such as milk, juice, and water.

It can be drizzled on something or spread on top with a spoon.

This type of icing has more shine and a smoother consistency than frosting does. (source)

How do you thicken milk for frosting?

To thicken the milk, mix a thickener such as cornstarch, tapioca, or arrowroot starch.

Remove from the stove as soon as the frosting begins to thicken.

Cornstarch is probably the most popular thickener because it tastes neutral and has a low gloss finish.

Is heavy cream or milk better for frosting?

You can use both heavy cream and whole milk for icing.

The purpose of the liquid is to thin the icing to a spreadable consistency.

You will probably need less milk than cream because it is thinner. (source)

Can frosting made with milk sit out?

Yes, frosting made with milk is safe at room temperature for two to three days.

If you are going to leave a cake with cream cheese frosting out before serving it, put it in the refrigerator first. (source)

How long will homemade frosting last in the fridge?

Homemade frosting can last for one week in the refrigerator and up to one month in the freezer. (source)

Is icing better than frosting?

It’s not necessarily better, since they’re used for different purposes.

Frosting is thicker and is usually put on baked goods.

Icing is thinner and used as a glaze or to add shine or smoothness. (source)

Is frosting the same as whipped cream?

No, icing and whipped cream are different.

Icing has a different texture and tastes better than whipped cream.

What are the two types of frosting?

They’re buttercream and whipped cream.

Buttercream is a soft and spreadable icing.

Whipped cream is a light frosting.

milk substitute for frosting

Why is my frosting so runny?

You might have put too much milk in it, or the butter was too soft.

It could also be because you beat it too hard.

Or your kitchen might be hot and this makes the frosting runny.

Why is my frosting grainy?

The frosting was grainy because the powdered sugar was made of beet sugar.

So next time you need to buy powdered sugar, make sure it is made from cane sugar.

It might also be too sweet, so don’t worry if you have to add some water or milk.

How to fix my wet frosting?

If your frosting is too sweet, you can mix butter, salt, powdered sugar, and milk.

This helps get rid of the taste that is too sweet.

Why does my cream cheese frosting go runny?

Sometimes the cream cheese in the frosting will turn runny.

This usually happens when the liquid from the cream cheese mixes with other ingredients in the frosting, like sugar.

It will not fix this problem to add more sugar and it may lead to a frosting that is too sweet.

Can I use half and half instead of heavy cream for frosting?

Yes, you can use half and half instead of heavy cream.

Replace the heavy cream with an equal amount of half and half.

It will cut the calories and fat in your recipe, without sacrificing flavor.

Half and half do not need to be whipped as long as you are using it instead of heavy cream because it has less fat. (source)


I loved the taste of this frosting and how it was light, fluffy, and buttery.

The coconut milk gave it a rich flavor that made me feel like I can eat more than just one bite.

I would highly recommend giving these recipes a try if you’re looking for ways to cut down on cow milk in your diet or simply want an amazing-tasting recipe with less sugar.

What other substitutions do you think will work best for this case?

Tamara Pierce

Tamara Pierce is a food writer at Elapasony, passionate about exploring diverse cuisines and sharing recipes and food experiences. From trendy restaurants to local hotspots, she's always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors.

Recent Posts