Soda Showdown: Dr Pepper Dethrones Pepsi in America’s Hearts

After a century of battling America’s soft drink giants, Dr Pepper has officially overtaken Pepsi as America’s second favorite soda.

The Undisputed Second Best?

Image Credit: Pexels / Martin Péchy

Pepsi has historically placed second to Coca-Cola as America’s favorite sugary carbonated beverage. But now, another type of soda has taken its place – Dr Pepper. 

Outpacing Pepsi

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Pickadook

New data from Beverage Digest, which provides data analysis for the global beverage industry, shows that Dr Pepper has overtaken Pepsi to win the spot of America’s second most-purchased soda behind Coke.

A 0.03% Difference

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Freedomz

Beverage Digest reported that Dr Pepper had claimed 8.34% of the country’s soda market last year, compared to Pepsi’s 8.31%. While the 0.03% difference is minimal, it signifies the soaring popularity of Dr Pepper over the last few decades.

Hailing from Texas

Image Credit: Shutterstock / rarrarorro

The classic soft drink was first created in 1885 in Waco, Texas, and was nationally marketed in the US in 1904. It is actually older than its greatest rival, Coca-Cola, which was not marketed as such until a year after Dr. Pepper.

A Favorite in the South

Image Credit: Shutterstock / topperspix

Though it did not grab the nation’s attention as swiftly and effectively as Coca-Cola, it remained a regional favorite in Southern states, marketing itself as a “spicy” alternative to Coke with its signature blend of 23 different flavors.

Two Decades of Increased Success

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Giorgia Basso

While it has long been considered a classic of America’s carbonated beverage catalog, this has only been reflected in the numbers in the last 20-30 years.

From 6th to 2nd

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Pressmaster

24 years ago at the beginning of the century, Dr. Pepper was placed as America’s 6th favorite soft drink, according to data at the time. 

Improvements Year After Year

Image Credit: Shutterstock / PanuShot

It had the sixth largest market share in 2000, behind Coke, Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sprite, and Diet Coke. Since then, it has begun steadily jumping the soda ranks, taking 5th place in 2004 (tied with Sprite), before ascending to second place last year. 

Technical Tie, Marginal Win

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Ground Picture

Dr Pepper and Pepsi’s numbers are technically tied as they both sit at 8.3% market share, but the thin margin for Dr Pepper is a notable blow for its competitors.

Pepsi Falling Behind

Image Credit: Pexels / Long Tang

Pepsi has held the second-place position, both in market share and in consumer hearts and popular culture, since 1985. It has long been considered the “next best thing” to Coke, but that perspective may now be changing. 

“They’re Meeting in the Middle”

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Salivanchuk Semen

“Dr Pepper has been gaining, [Pepsi] has been declining, and they’re meeting in the middle,” said Duane Stanford, a Beverage Digest editor, about the latest data.

Interesting, Experimental Choices

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Leigh Prather

Some of Dr Pepper’s modern success can be attributed to its daring and experimental marketing. In particular, it has introduced a range of unique and unusual flavor profiles, several of which have been a hit with consumers.

Two Wildly Successful Flavors

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Billy F Blume Jr

Most notable were the Strawberries & Cream Dr Pepper introduced last year and the Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut, both of which were very successful and even garnered viral attention.

“The Only Coconut-Cream-Flavored Dark Soda”

Image Credit: Shutterstock / SKphotographer

The latter, which was introduced in May, was marketed as the “only coconut-cream-flavored dark soda on the market,” in a press release.

Soft Drink of the Summer?

Image Credit: Shutterstock / New Africa

It is now the brand’s 24th flavor and one of its most successful. The release described it as “layers of tropical coconut flavor and a delicious, creamy finish,” and it is on its way to being the quintessential drink of the summer this year. 

A Huge Portfolio

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Alfa Photostudio

Stanford attributed Pepsi’s flagging success to the company’s diversification, as it has moved to focus on a range of other food brands that fall under the company umbrella, such as Quaker and Frito-Lay.

Focus on “Zero Sugar”

Image Credit: Pexels / SverreVegard

Pepsi has also begun focusing on promoting “zero sugar” beverages rather than their classic recipe, which may have turned a section of customers away. “They’re leading with that now,” Stanford explained. 

No Competition for Coke

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Niloo

Coke, on the other hand, is still facing very little competition in terms of market share, as it continues its century-long domination of the soft drink industry.

More Than Both Combined

Image Credit: Shutterstock / wutzkohphoto

While Dr Pepper and Pepsi battle it out over an 8.3% market share, Beverage Digest data shows that Coke still raked in 19.2% of the soda market – more than both its competitor brands combined.

1.9 Billion Servings

Image Credit: Shutterstock / sdx15

It’s not just America either – Coke remains the most purchased and consumed soda across the globe, with 1.9 billion servings issued across 200 countries last year, as shared by brand valuation consultancy Brand Finance. 

Timeless Taste: 20 Boomer Superfoods That Are Making a Comeback

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Civil

Discover the forgotten superfoods of the boomer generation! From liver to sardines, these nutritional powerhouses are making a comeback. Join us as we rediscover these classic ingredients and their health benefits. Let’s dive into the world of boomer superfoods together! Timeless Taste: 20 Boomer Superfoods That Are Making a Comeback

21 Everyday Grocery Items That Are Loaded With Chemicals

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Elena Veselova

Grocery shopping can seem like a science experiment, with many products packed with artificial additives instead of nutrients. While convenient and tempting, have you considered what’s really in these items? 21 Everyday Grocery Items That Are Loaded With Chemicals

18 Must-Eat Foods for a Longer Life

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Nungning20

In the quest for a longer life, certain foods can make a big difference. From everyday staples to exotic finds, these options span various budgets and might surprise you. Who knew the secret to longevity could be right in your pantry or at the grocery store? 18 Must-Eat Foods for a Longer Life

Featured Image Credit: Pexels / Brandon Richardson.

For transparency, this content was partly developed with AI assistance and carefully curated by an experienced editor to be informative and ensure accuracy.

Recent Posts